FIN-98-077
Survivorship Bias and Attrition Effects in Measures of Performance Persistence
Jennifer N. Carpenter and Anthony W. Lynch    October 1998
 Abstract     
We generate samples of fund returns calibrated to match the U.S. mutual fund industry and simulate standard tests of performance persistence. We consider a variety of alternative return generating processes, survival criteria, and test methodologies. When survival depends on performance over several periods, survivorship bias induces spurious reversals, despite the presence of cross-sectional heteroskedasticity in performance. In samples which are largely free of survivorship bias, look-ahead biased methodologies and missing returns still affect statistics. In samples with no true persistence, the spurious persistence caused by survivorship bias in the presence of single-period survival criteria never reaches the magnitude found in recent empirical studies. When fund returns are truly persistent, the simulations reveal an attrition effect, distinct from survivorship bias. The systematic disappearance of poor performers causes mean persistence measures to differ from those in a hypothetical sample in which funds never disappear, even in tests which incorporate all data on disappearing funds. The magnitude and direction of this effect depends on the return generating process. We also examine the specification and power of the persistence tests. The t-test for the difference between top and bottom portfolios ranked by past performance is the best specified under the null and among the most powerful against the alternatives we consider.
 Jennifer N. Carpenter     
Institution: Stern School of Business, New York University
Email: jcarpen0@stern.nyu.edu
Home Page: http://www.stern.nyu.edu/~jcarpen0
 Anthony W. Lynch     
Institution: Stern School of Business, New York University
Email: alynch@stern.nyu.edu
Home Page: http://www.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch

  To download a copy of this paper click here.
    Please note: When electronic originals are not available, archived Working Papers are scanned from hard copies.

The 1998 Department of Finance Working Paper Series has been generously sponsored by